Philosophy & Ethics 770 words

Harriet Tubman and Her Journey Towards Freedom

Sample Essay

Harriet Tubman's life story is more than a historical account; it is a profound ethical narrative of courage, conviction, and the relentless pursuit of human dignity. Born into the brutal institution of slavery in Dorchester County, Maryland, around 1822, Tubman (born Araminta Ross) would become one of the most iconic figures in American history, not only for her personal escape from bondage but for her unwavering dedication to liberating hundreds of others. Her journey towards freedom was not a solitary act of self-preservation but a principled stand against an immoral system, guided by a deep-seated belief in the inherent right to liberty. Examining her actions through an ethical lens reveals a moral compass that prioritized justice and humanity above personal safety or societal norms.

Tubman's most significant ethical contribution lies in her active participation in the Underground Railroad. After her own daring escape in 1849, she could have retreated to safety in the North and lived a life free from the immediate threat of recapture. Instead, she repeatedly risked her freedom and her life, venturing back into the slaveholding South on at least thirteen missions to guide enslaved people to freedom. This act of altruism, bordering on heroic defiance, challenges any notion that survival alone was her motivation. Her courage stemmed from a profound ethical imperative: the conviction that slavery was a profound injustice that demanded active resistance. Her famous declaration, "I had reasoned this out in my mind; there was one of two things I had a right to, liberty or death; if I could not have one, I would have the other," encapsulates this unwavering commitment to freedom as a fundamental human right. This wasn't just about escaping; it was about liberating others from an existential threat.

The ethical framework guiding Tubman’s actions can be understood through the lens of natural rights philosophy, particularly the idea that all individuals possess inherent rights not granted by any government or society. The Declaration of Independence, though hypocritically applied in its time, articulated the ideal of "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness." Tubman, operating in a society that denied these very rights to enslaved people, embodied the spirit of this ideal. Her actions were a practical application of this philosophy, asserting the natural right to liberty for herself and for those she helped. She didn't wait for legal or political change; she acted on a moral imperative that transcended the flawed legal structures of her era. Her reliance on faith and divine guidance also played a significant role in her ethical decision-making, providing her with the strength and conviction to undertake such dangerous missions.

Furthermore, Tubman's approach to leadership and her operational methods on the Underground Railroad demonstrate a sophisticated ethical intelligence. She was known for her pragmatism, her meticulous planning, and her decisive action. She carried a pistol, not for aggression, but as a deterrent and a means to enforce her will when necessary, particularly to prevent despondent escapees from turning back, which would have endangered the entire group. Her strict discipline, often summarized in her stern pronouncements like "You'll be free or die," were not born of cruelty but of a deep understanding of the extreme risks involved. Every backward step, every moment of doubt, could lead to capture, torture, and the return to slavery for everyone involved. Her ethical responsibility extended beyond individual freedom to the collective success and safety of the group under her care. This required a balance of compassion and unwavering resolve.

In her later years, Tubman continued her fight for justice, becoming an active participant in the women's suffrage movement. This later activism further solidifies her status as a lifelong champion of human rights. Her willingness to continue advocating for the rights of others, even after enduring so much hardship and achieving her own freedom, highlights a consistent ethical commitment. She understood that the fight for equality was multifaceted and interconnected. Her experiences as an enslaved woman informed her understanding of oppression, making her a powerful voice for both racial and gender equality.

Harriet Tubman's journey towards freedom is a powerful testament to the human spirit and the moral imperative to fight injustice. Her life illustrates that true freedom is not merely the absence of chains but the active pursuit of liberty and dignity for all. Her actions, driven by a profound ethical conviction and an unwavering commitment to justice, continue to inspire movements for freedom and equality worldwide. Her legacy is not just in the lives she saved but in the enduring moral example she set: that one person, armed with courage and a strong ethical compass, can indeed change the world.

Analysis

The essay presents a clear and compelling thesis: Harriet Tubman's journey towards freedom was fundamentally an ethical narrative driven by a profound conviction in the inherent right to liberty. The structure is logical, moving from her personal escape to her broader activism on the Underground Railroad and later advocacy. Body paragraphs develop the thesis by providing specific examples: her repeated risks on the Underground Railroad, her philosophical justification for her actions ("liberty or death"), and her pragmatic leadership methods. The tone is respectful and admiring, but grounded in ethical analysis rather than mere hagiography. The use of specific details, like her birth name, location, and the number of missions, adds weight to the arguments.

Key Considerations

While the essay effectively frames Tubman's actions through natural rights philosophy, it could explore alternative ethical frameworks, such as utilitarianism (though her actions were clearly driven by more than just maximizing good outcomes) or deontology (duty-based ethics). A deeper dive into the specific moral dilemmas she faced – for instance, when she might have had to make difficult choices that impacted individuals for the sake of the group – could add further complexity. The essay might also benefit from briefly acknowledging the historical context that made her actions so radical and dangerous, contrasting her ethical stance with the prevailing societal norms that upheld slavery.

Recommendations

For a student adapting this essay, focus on integrating your thesis statement smoothly into the introduction. Instead of simply listing facts, ensure each piece of evidence directly supports your central argument about Tubman's ethical journey. When discussing her actions, explain why they were ethically significant. Avoid generalizations; use specific examples like the "liberty or death" quote. Ensure your conclusion doesn't just summarize but offers a final thought on the enduring relevance of her ethical example. Be mindful of sentence variety to maintain reader engagement.

Frequently Asked Questions

Harriet Tubman was driven by a profound belief in the inherent, natural right to liberty for all individuals, viewing slavery as a fundamental injustice that demanded active resistance.

Her own successful escape in 1849 did not lead to passive safety but instead fueled her resolve to risk her freedom repeatedly to liberate others.

She faced immense ethical challenges, including the need to maintain strict discipline and make difficult decisions that prioritized the safety of the group over individual wavering.

Tubman later became a passionate advocate for women's suffrage, demonstrating a consistent commitment to broader human rights and equality.