Media & Arts Review essay 536 words

Musical Review of Les Miserables En Concert a Paris

Sample Essay

The grand scale of Les Misérables is often its most celebrated aspect, and Les Misérables En Concert, Paris—recorded at the Bastille Opera House in 2010—aimed to amplify this already considerable presence. The production's undertaking to translate the epic narrative and soaring score of the stage musical into a concert format, without sets or traditional staging, presented a significant challenge. However, by focusing on vocal prowess and the sheer power of the ensemble, this En Concert successfully delivers a deeply resonant and emotionally charged rendition of the beloved show, proving that the heart of Les Mis lies not in its scenery, but in its stories and songs.

One of the concert's greatest triumphs is its casting. Featuring an array of internationally acclaimed performers, the vocal performances are uniformly exceptional. Alfie Boe, stepping into the role of Jean Valjean, imbues the character with a profound weariness and eventual, hard-won grace. His rendition of "Bring Him Home" is particularly moving, a moment of quiet desperation and faith that silences the arena. Similarly, Norm Lewis as Javert brings a steely resolve and unwavering conviction to his role, his powerful baritone cutting through the orchestration with imposing authority. The famous "Stars" sequence, delivered with chilling precision, underscores Javert's rigid adherence to the law. The supporting cast is equally strong, with standout performances from Lea Salonga as Fantine, whose "I Dreamed a Dream" is a masterclass in raw vulnerability, and Jenny Galloway, who injects Madame Thénardier with her characteristic dark humor and theatricality. These performances, unburdened by the need for physical acting, are allowed to fully inhabit the emotional core of each character.

The concert's directorial choice to utilize a massive chorus and a full symphony orchestra, rather than a traditional pit orchestra, significantly contributes to the overwhelming sonic experience. The sheer volume and richness of the sound are breathtaking, filling the vast space of the Bastille Opera. The scale of the ensemble allows for moments like the "One Day More" sequence to become truly monumental, a whirlwind of individual hopes and fears colliding on the eve of revolution. The sheer force of the combined voices and instruments elevates the dramatic tension, making each musical number feel like a pivotal event. While the absence of sets might initially seem like a drawback, it forces the audience to focus on the music and the performers, stripping away visual distractions and allowing the emotional narratives to take center stage. The use of subtle lighting and projections, while minimal, effectively supports the mood of each scene without overpowering the central performances.

Ultimately, Les Misérables En Concert, Paris succeeds because it understands that the enduring appeal of this musical lies in its universal themes of redemption, sacrifice, and the indomitable human spirit. The concert format, rather than diminishing these themes, actually amplifies them by placing the power of the human voice and the grandeur of the score front and center. It is a testament to the strength of Boublil and Schönberg's composition and Alain Boublil and Jean-Marc Natel's adaptation that a concert staging can evoke such potent emotional responses. The recording captures a powerful, albeit different, experience of Les Mis, one that celebrates the raw talent of its performers and the undeniable impact of its music.

Analysis

The essay's thesis, that Les Misérables En Concert, Paris successfully delivers a resonant and emotionally charged rendition by focusing on vocal prowess and ensemble power, provides a clear roadmap for the review. The structure is logical, opening with an introduction that sets up the premise and thesis, followed by body paragraphs that each explore a key aspect of the production—casting and vocal performance, and the impact of the concert format and scale. Evidence is provided through specific mentions of key performers like Alfie Boe, Norm Lewis, and Lea Salonga, and their notable songs, such as "Bring Him Home" and "I Dreamed a Dream." The analysis of the sonic experience, referencing the full symphony orchestra and massive chorus, also serves as concrete evidence. The tone is appreciative and analytical, avoiding hyperbole while still conveying enthusiasm for the production's strengths.

Key Considerations

While the essay highlights the vocal strengths, a more nuanced discussion could explore the potential drawbacks of a concert format for a narrative-driven musical. For instance, how effectively are character relationships and plot developments conveyed without the visual cues of staging and acting? A counterargument might question whether the sheer volume of the orchestra and chorus, while impressive, sometimes overwhelms individual vocal moments or the subtler emotional nuances of certain songs. Additionally, while specific actors are named, further comparative analysis against other Les Mis productions, or deeper exploration of the directing choices within the concert framework, could add another layer of critical depth.

Recommendations

When adapting this review, students should ensure their thesis is clearly stated early on and then consistently supported by specific examples. Don't just say performances were "good"; name the actors and the songs that exemplify their skill. Be descriptive about the sound and feel of the production, not just the plot. Avoid vague praise; instead, explain why something worked. Ensure transitions between paragraphs are smooth, linking ideas logically. Remember to focus on the specific production being reviewed, not just the musical in general.

Frequently Asked Questions

The main argument is that *Les Misérables En Concert, Paris* successfully captures the emotional power of the musical through exceptional vocal performances and a grand, scaled-up orchestral and choral presentation.

The review highlights Alfie Boe as Jean Valjean, Norm Lewis as Javert, Lea Salonga as Fantine, and Jenny Galloway as Madame Thénardier for their significant vocal contributions.

The review doesn't explicitly criticize the production but notes the challenge of translating a narrative musical to a concert format without traditional staging.

The concert format, by emphasizing vocal performance and the full orchestra/chorus, allows the emotional core of the story and music to be the primary focus, unburdened by visual distractions.