Literature & Books 744 words

The Great Gatsby and Prohibition

Sample Essay

F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby, set against the backdrop of the Roaring Twenties, is more than a tragic love story; it's a searing indictment of the American Dream's corruption, a decay directly fueled by the era's defining social experiment: Prohibition. Enacted in 1920 with the noble intention of curbing societal ills, the Volstead Act ultimately bred a culture of hypocrisy, illegal enterprise, and moral bankruptcy that permeates Gatsby's world. Through Jay Gatsby's illicit fortune, the opulent yet hollow parties, and the pervasive dishonesty of its characters, the novel demonstrates how the ban on alcohol did not purify society but instead exposed and exacerbated its deepest flaws, twisting the pursuit of happiness into a desperate, ultimately destructive, scramble for wealth and status.

Jay Gatsby himself is the embodiment of this corruption. His immense wealth, the ostentatious displays of which define his West Egg mansion and legendary parties, is derived from bootlegging and other illegal activities. This is not mere background detail; it is the very foundation of his social standing and his desperate attempt to recapture the past. Gatsby believes that accumulating vast wealth, even through illicit means, is the key to winning back Daisy Buchanan, the object of his obsessive affection. His dream, initially a romantic ideal, becomes entangled with the spoils of a criminal underworld, highlighting how Prohibition created opportunities for the unscrupulous to thrive. The legal prohibition of alcohol created a massive black market, and Gatsby, a product of this environment, rose to prominence by exploiting it. His success is a perversion of the traditional American Dream, which once valued hard work and honest enterprise. Instead, Gatsby’s dream is built on a foundation of illegal liquor, gambling, and likely more sinister enterprises, showcasing how the legal framework meant to improve society inadvertently fostered its criminal elements.

The lavish parties hosted by Gatsby, while appearing to celebrate the excesses of the Jazz Age, actually serve to underscore the hollowness and moral ambiguity fostered by Prohibition. These gatherings are spectacles of excess, filled with uninvited guests and an atmosphere of frantic gaiety. Yet, beneath the surface of champagne and jazz, there is a profound emptiness. The attendees, often wealthy and influential, indulge in free-flowing (and illegally obtained) alcohol, flaunting their disregard for the law. They are drawn to Gatsby not for his character or his history, but for the sheer spectacle and the readily available forbidden pleasure. This superficial engagement mirrors the societal attitude towards Prohibition itself – a law widely ignored by those who could afford to break it, revealing a widespread hypocrisy. The constant presence of alcohol, a forbidden commodity, fuels the recklessness and irresponsibility that ultimately leads to tragedy, particularly in the fatal car accident involving Myrtle Wilson. The very thing meant to be absent from society is its most visible and destructive element.

The characters surrounding Gatsby further illuminate the moral decay amplified by Prohibition. Tom Buchanan, a man of old money and ingrained privilege, openly flouts the law, engaging in an affair with Myrtle Wilson and participating in the illicit liquor trade through his associates. His wealth insulates him from the consequences of his actions, a common theme for the elite in this era. Myrtle, trapped by her social circumstances, sees her affair with Tom and her association with Gatsby as an escape route, a way to access the forbidden pleasures and material comforts that alcohol, and the wealth it generates, represents. Even Nick Carraway, the narrator, finds himself drawn into this world of corruption, initially repulsed but gradually becoming accustomed to the moral compromises. His eventual disillusionment stems not just from the personal tragedies but from the pervasive dishonesty and the way the pursuit of wealth, often fueled by illegal activities made possible by Prohibition, has corrupted the very idea of the American Dream, transforming it into a pursuit of superficial pleasures and hollow status.

In conclusion, The Great Gatsby masterfully employs the context of Prohibition to critique the American Dream. The law, intended to foster a more virtuous society, instead created a fertile ground for corruption, hypocrisy, and moral decay. Jay Gatsby's rise and fall, the hollow celebrations at his mansion, and the actions of the privileged elite all demonstrate how the ban on alcohol did not eradicate societal problems but rather amplified them. Fitzgerald shows that when a society attempts to legislate morality, it often breeds the opposite, leaving individuals like Gatsby chasing a corrupted dream built on the shaky foundations of illegality and illusion.

Analysis

The essay presents a clear, arguable thesis: that The Great Gatsby uses Prohibition to expose the corruption of the American Dream. This thesis is developed through a logical structure, beginning with Gatsby as the central figure, moving to the symbolic parties, and then examining the surrounding characters. The body paragraphs offer specific examples: Gatsby's bootlegging, the "uninvited guests" and "forbidden pleasure" at his parties, and the hypocrisy of characters like Tom Buchanan. The tone is analytical and critical, effectively conveying Fitzgerald's critique without resorting to overly academic jargon. The essay consistently links the social context of Prohibition to the novel's thematic concerns, providing a cohesive argument.

Key Considerations

While the essay effectively links Prohibition to the American Dream's corruption, it could explore the irony of the dream's pursuit more deeply. For instance, how did the spirit of the Jazz Age, often associated with rebellion and excess, interact with the letter of Prohibition? A stronger version might also delve into the specific types of illegal activities Gatsby was involved in, if the text hints at them, or contrast his methods with other bootleggers. Additionally, examining how Prohibition might have influenced the illusion of wealth and status, making it more attainable through illicit means, could add another layer.

Recommendations

Do clearly state your thesis early on and ensure every paragraph directly supports it. Use specific examples from the text (character actions, party descriptions) to back up your points, rather than general statements. Maintain a consistent, analytical tone throughout. Don't just summarize plot points; explain how they illustrate your argument about Prohibition and the American Dream. Avoid vague language and connect Fitzgerald's critique to the historical context of the 1920s. Be sure to explain the significance of the evidence you present.

Frequently Asked Questions

Prohibition created a black market for alcohol, allowing individuals like Gatsby to amass wealth through illegal means, thus corrupting the traditional ideal of achieving success through honest work.

Gatsby's lavish parties, fueled by illegal liquor, symbolize the era's hypocrisy and the superficial pursuit of pleasure, demonstrating how the forbidden nature of alcohol amplified excess.

Tom Buchanan, a wealthy man who openly flouts Prohibition laws and profits from the illegal liquor trade, exemplifies the hypocrisy and moral decay that the ban inadvertently fostered among the elite.

Fitzgerald's novel suggests that while Prohibition aimed to improve society, its implementation led to widespread corruption and moral compromise, ultimately twisting the pursuit of the American Dream into something hollow and destructive.

Need an original paper?

This sample is for study and inspiration. Get a custom, plagiarism-free essay written for you.

Order an Original Try the AI Humanizer